The Best Movie Of 2023

For most of the year, I was ready to call Blackberry the best film of the year (and you really ought to see it), but no, it’s The Holdovers. A truly lovely film that heavily recalls the early work of Tobias Wolff, Peter Bogdanovich, and maybe a little bit of JD Salinger.

I Will Justify The Ways Of Christmas To Man

“My suspicion, then, is that as mankind gains more and more control over nature, we will need Christmas to begin earlier and earlier. If we are impatient, we are impatient to escape the atheistic world of time in which modernity has trapped us.

“So,” sneers the grinch, “you’d prefer Christmas to begin in January? Is that what you’re shilling for now?” Well, in a manner of speaking, yes. Absolutely.”

-from There’s A Good Reason The Christmas Season Keeps Getting Longer, my latest for CiRCE

Decluttering Your Way To Hell

“Americans have so many things that a certain kind of book has lately proliferated which is expressly designed to make readers want to get rid of their things, and to feel good about it. Simplicity and minimalism are hot ticket non-items this year. Of course, minimalism is really just another kind of thing you buy. We purchase food dehydrators as the accoutrements of diets which will help us lose weight so we can feel chic in our black mock-turtleneck sweaters… and then we purchase books telling us to simplify, to get rid of our food dehydrators, and we tell ourselves that such simplicity is part of a new, sleek, more European image we are adopting, which will, incidentally, need to be accessorized with a black mock-turtleneck sweater. Americans do not actually know this is European, but it seems European, for every American keeps a somewhat Romantic notion that somewhere in Sweden, or Austria, or Belgium, or perhaps Tokyo, there is a certain kind of sleek, sophisticated way of life which comes from wearing black, drinking white wine, having no children, and knowing who Mark Rothko is. Even ugly, stupid people in Austria know who Mark Rothko is. Austrian people are Criterion Collection human beings.”

-from Decluttering and Simplifying Your Way To Hell

How Do You Test On That?

“First, your work needs to be typed, printed, and stapled in the top left corner.

Second, you need to use the Calibri font and may not mess with margins.

Third, the paper itself needs to be pristine. If it’s wrinkled at all, I won’t accept it. Seriously.

Fourth, your work needs to be signed by a parent. Your parent’s signature should go below the last line on the last page.

Fifth, you may not extensively quote from any work. You may include two quotations, neither of which may be longer than ten words.

Sixth, do not print on both sides. Print on one side only.

Seventh, in the top left corner of the first page, put your name, your section, the date, and my name. This assignment should not have a title.

NOTE: On the day this work is due, I will inspect each individual submission before accepting it. If your work doesn’t meet the requirements listed above, your work will not be accepted. You will have to submit it the following day at a twenty-point penalty.”

-My latest for CiRCE offers a little help to younger teachers who have to give longer writing assignments.

Unintended Telos

There is a sense in which German higher criticism is simply a reductio ad absurdum of historical-grammatical hermeneutics.

The problem for those who depend entirely on historical-grammatical hermeneutics isn’t that higher criticism is wrong, but that it’s entirely possible within such a hermeneutical framework. In other words, the problem isn’t the assertions of higher criticism, but insufficient proof to back them up; however, this could change with a few archaeological discoveries.

I say all this as someone who is deeply impressed by Austin Farrer and Dale Allison Jr.